Synthesis 2022; 54(06): 1478-1502
DOI: 10.1055/a-1677-5971
short review

Alkylation Reactions with Alkylsulfonium Salts

Ze-Yu Tian
a   School of Materials Science and Engineering, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan, 430070, P. R. of China
b   School of Chemistry, Chemical Engineering and Life Science, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan, 430070, P. R. of China
,
Yu Ma
b   School of Chemistry, Chemical Engineering and Life Science, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan, 430070, P. R. of China
,
a   School of Materials Science and Engineering, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan, 430070, P. R. of China
b   School of Chemistry, Chemical Engineering and Life Science, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan, 430070, P. R. of China
› Author Affiliations

We thank Wuhan University of Technology, the ‘Hundred Talent’ Program of Hubei Province (China), and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (2019-YB-002 and 2020-YB-003) for financial support.
 


Abstract

The application of alkylsulfonium salts as alkyl-transfer reagents in organic synthesis has reemerged over the past few years. Numerous heteroatom- and carbon-centered nucleophiles, alkenes, arenes, alkynes, organometallic reagents, and others are readily alkylated by alkylsulfonium salts under mild conditions. The reactions feature convenience, high efficiency, readily accessible and structurally diversified alkylation reagents, good functional group tolerance, and a wide range of substrate types, allowing the facile synthesis of various useful organic molecules from commercially available building blocks. This review summarizes alkylation reactions using either isolated or in situ formed alkylsulfonium salts via nucleophilic substitution, transition-metal-catalyzed reactions, and photoredox processes.

1 Introduction

2 General Methods for the Synthesis of Alkylsulfonium Salts

3 Electrophilic Alkylation Using Alkylsulfonium Salts

4 Transition-Metal-Catalyzed Alkylation Using Alkylsulfonium Salts

5 Photoredox-Catalyzed Alkylation Using Alkylsulfonium Salts

6 Conclusion


# 1

Introduction

Zoom Image
Ze-Yu Tianis a Ph.D. student at Wuhan University of Technology. He joined the research group of Prof. Cheng-Pan Zhang in November 2016. His research interests are the synthesis and cross-couplings of aryl- and alkylsulfonium salts under transition-metal-catalyzed or transition-metal-free conditions. Yu Ma is a third-year master’s student in the research group of Prof. Cheng-Pan Zhang at Wuhan University of Technology. He obtained his bachelor’s degree in Pharmacy from Hebei University in 2019. His research interests mainly focus on transition-metal-catalyzed allylation with alkylsulfonium salts and its application in drug synthesis. Cheng-Pan Zhang obtained his bachelor’s degree in Pharmacy from Chongqing Medical University in 2005. He received his Ph.D. degree from the Shanghai Institute of Organic Chemistry in 2011 under the supervision of Prof. Ji-Chang Xiao. He was a postdoctoral fellow in Prof. David A. Vicic’s group at the University of Hawai’i from 2011 to 2012. Then, he worked with Prof. John A. Gladysz in Texas A&M University. In 2014, he joined Wuhan University of Technology as a full professor. His current research interests are the reactions of sulfonium salts and the development of transition-metal-catalyzed fluoroalkylation.

Sulfonium salts are widely present in functional materials, natural products, and bioactive molecules.[1] [2] [3] They have a positive charge on the sulfur centers bearing three C–S bonds and show rich reactivity due to their structural diversity, being one of the most important class of organosulfur(IV) species.[1] The selective cleavage of C–S bonds in sulfonium salts is of fundamental significance. Alkylsulfonium salts represent a subclass of sulfonium(IV) salts, containing at least one ‘alkyl-S+’ fragment in their structures, and have played an important role in materials and life sciences (Figure [1]).[3] Sulfonium polymers, prepared from methylation of sulfur-containing compounds in light oil with iodomethane and AgBF4 during desulfurization, were used as thermal latent initiators for the cationic ring-opening polymerization of epoxides.[3a] [b] The properties of alkylsulfonium salts as photoacid generators under UV/visible-light irradiation were also described.[3c] [d] Alkylsulfonium-containing zwitterionic polymers, synthesized by controlled RAFT polymerization and subsequent modification, exhibited low cytotoxicities and were demonstrated to be superior protein stabilizers compared to dimethylsulfoniopropionate and other conventional stabilizers.[3e] The ROS-responsive polysulfoniums that degrade into uncharged sulfide fragments by intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) can efficiently dissociate and release DNA for gene expression, which deliver the suicide gene to intraperitoneal tumors in vivo, eliciting high anticancer activity.[3f] S-Adenosylmethionine (SAM) is the biological methyl donor in most cases sustaining a wide range of biological processes, including gene expression, protein modification, lipid biosynthesis, and many other metabolic pathways.[4]

Zoom Image
Figure 1 The broad application of alkylsulfonium salts

In the fields of organic chemistry, alkylsulfonium salts have drawn increasing attention because they can serve as versatile reagents or intermediates to offer simple, effective, and selective access to target structures, including the late-stage modification of complex molecules (Figure [1]).[5] Alkylsulfonium salts have been generally used as precursors of sulfur ylides for the synthesis of diverse organic scaffolds through the Johnson–Corey–Chaykovsky reaction, cyclization, rearrangement, and cross-coupling.[5] Perfluoroalkyl(diaryl)sulfonium salts, the fluorinated version of alkyl(diaryl)sulfonium salts, are well-known electrophilic perfluoroalkylation agents (e.g., Yagupolskii–Umemoto reagents), achieving a large number of useful methods for introducing perfluoroalkyl groups into organic compounds.[6] The dealkylative functionalization of alkylsulfonium salts has also been explored to conveniently afford elegant sulfides.[7] Inspired by the biological relevance of triorganosulfonium salts as alkylating reagents,[4] alkylation using alkylsulfonium salts has flourished over the past few years and has become one of the major focuses for synthetic chemists. Although a series of reviews have highlighted transformations of sulfoniums as cross-coupling partners or intermediates to form valuable compounds, the use of alkylsulfonium salts as alkyl-transfer reagents via C–S bond cleavage has not yet been systematically summarized in the literature.[1c] , [5`] [c] [d] [e] [f] [g] [h] [i] [j] [k] [l] , [8]

Considering the advances of alkylation with alkylsulfonium salts in recent years, it would be indispensable to provide a short review of the findings in the field. For the sake of convenience, we have summarized the alkylation reactions of alkylsulfonium salts in this article and organized them in three parts according to their possible reaction mechanisms: electrophilic alkylation, transition-metal-catalyzed alkylation, and photoredox-catalyzed alkylation. To aid the readers, the representative synthetic methods of alkylsulfonium salts as well as the selectivity of alkylation reactions with alkylsulfonium salts containing three different C–S bonds are also discussed in this review. Thanks to the significant structural diversity and unique aspects of alkylsulfonium salts, developing general, efficient, and selective alkylation methods with alkylsulfonium salts is a challenging task in organic synthesis. Alkylation using alkylsulfonium salts is still one of the least acknowledged research fields in sulfur chemistry. We anticipate that this review will help new researchers to quickly develop an understanding of the subject and will stimulate further interest from the synthetic community to survey the new reactivity and application of alkylsulfonium salts.


# 2

General Methods for the Synthesis of Alkylsulfonium Salts

In most cases, alkylsulfonium salts are prepared from the substitution reactions of sulfides with alkyl halides, alcohols, and esters, the interrupted Pummerer reactions of activated sulfoxides with arenes, alkenes, and alkynes, or the addition of thianthrene radical cations with alkenes (Figure [2]).[1] [5] [8] [9] The in situ generation of alkylsulfonium salts from the addition of aryne intermediates with alkyl sulfides or the assembly of sulfide radical cations with alkyl radicals has also been demonstrated in sulfide-participated alkylation reactions.[1] [5] [8] [9] It should be mentioned that unstable alkylsulfonium salts are generally synthesized at low temperatures. Moreover, sulfur ylides undergoing protonation, alkylation, or combination with other electrophiles at the negative α-carbon centers form alkylsulfonium intermediates that are powerful alkylation reagents for diverse nucleophiles in one-pot procedures.[5]

Zoom Image
Figure 2 General synthetic methods for alkylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Figure 3 Different alkylation reactions with alkylsulfonium salts

# 3

Electrophilic Alkylation Using Alkylsulfonium Salts

It is well known that S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) is an efficient electrophilic methylation reagent in most biological processes because of the electron-deficient nature of the sulfonium group, which can react with various N-, O-, and S-nucleophiles, unsaturated carbons, and halide ions via typical SN2 displacement.[4] Nature also employs enzymes to catalyze the methylation of non-nucleophilic substrates with SAM via radical mechanisms, leading to transformations relevant to nucleic acid and protein modification, and to the biosynthesis of vitamins, coenzymes, and antibiotics. Taking a lesson from SAM as a powerful alkylation agent, trimethylsulfonium salts, trialkylsulfonium salts, dialkyl(aryl)sulfonium salts, and alkyl(diaryl)sulfonium salts have been comprehensively utilized to alkylate a variety of nucleophiles such as (thio)phenols, alcohols, thiols, amines, acids, 1,3-dicarbonyls, enolates, phosphine, Grignard reagents, alkyllithiums, azides, hydrides, halides, and others via SN2 reactions under transition-metal-free conditions (Figure [3a]).[10] The formation of sulfurane intermediates followed by reductive elimination, intramolecular substitution, or ionic fragmentation to afford alkylated products were also observed in the reactions with hard nucleophiles (e.g., n-butyllithium, enolate, carboxylate, and phenolate anions) (Figure [3b]).[10`] [h] [i] Furthermore, the SN1 mechanism was suggested for the reactions of alkyltetrathiafulvalenium intermediates with several nucleophiles (Figure [3b]).[11] It should be noted that the selective alkylation with alkylsulfonium salts bearing three different alkyl groups and the selective alkylation of nucleophiles containing more than one reactive site with certain alkylsulfonium salts is highly sought after (Figure [3c]).

3.1

Selective Alkylation with Acyclic and Cyclic Alkylsulfonium Salts

Selective alkylation is a long-term challenge in organic chemistry. Yamaguchi and co-workers found that uridine, thymidine, guanosine, inosine, theophylline, and 2-pyridone were methylated by [Me3S]F or [BuSMe2]F in DMF at 90–100 °C to give the corresponding N-methylated products in good yields. The counteranion of trimethylsulfonium had a big influence on the methylation as [Me3S]F converted uridine into 3-methyluridine quantitatively, whereas [Me3S]I did not react with uridine. Treatment of guanosine (1) with [Me3S]F formed 1-methylguanosine (2a) in 67% yield, while the similar reaction with [Me3S]I provided 7-methylguanosine (2b) in 54% yield (Scheme [1]).[12] The difference in the selectivity of methylation might be attributed to the hydrogen bonding between the fluoride anion and amide/imide groups in the substrates, which increased the nucleophilicity of the groups and enhanced the attack of sulfonium cations.

Zoom Image
Scheme 1 Selective N-alkylation of guanosine with trimethylsulfonium salts

In 2020, Shi and co-workers developed a selective d 3-methylation of complex molecules bearing several reactive sites with 5-(methyl-d 3)-5H-dibenzothiophen-5-ium triflate (DMTT, 3) (Scheme [2]).[13a] The reagent behaved as an analogue of SAM and was synthesized from dibenzothiophene and methyl-d 3 formate by following a TfOH-promoted S-alkylation procedure reported by Tsuchida (Scheme [2a]).[9h] DMTT had very different reactivity from other commonly used d 3-methylation reagents [CD3I and (CD3)2SO4] because of the steric hindrance of the leaving group, and exhibited better chemoselectivity than CD3I and (CD3)2SO4 in the d 3-methylation of 4-amino-2-hydroxybenzoic acid (4) to give methyl-d 3 4-amino-2-hydroxybenzoate (5) (Scheme [2b]).[13a] Reactions of primary amines with DMTT in the presence of 10 mol% Ni(OAc)2·4H2O selectively formed N,N-dimethyl-d 3 products in moderate to good yields, avoiding the overmethylation that frequently occurs in the direct methylation of primary amines with iodomethane to afford quaternary ammonium salts.[13a] This d 3-methylation proceeded smoothly under mild conditions with high-level deuterium incorporation and was applicable to the late-stage modification of pharmaceuticals with excellent functional group compatibility (Scheme [2c]). In 2021, the same research group reported the use of DMTT as a d 2-methylene source in the synthesis of α-deuterated boronates through a sulfur ylide mediated 1,2-migration reaction.[13b] Such boron-initiated, sulfur ylide mediated migration processes were similarly explored in detail by Aggarwal and others.[13`] [d] [e] [f] [g]

Zoom Image
Scheme 2 Selective d 3-methylation with DMTT
Zoom Image
Scheme 3 Selective alkylation of cyclic alkylsulfonium salts

In 1976, Eliel and co-workers found that the nucleophilic attack of 1-methyltetrahydrothiophenium (8a) (five-membered ring) by sodium azide or methanethiolate afforded the ring-opening products with small amounts of methylated products, while the similar reactions with 1-methyltetrahydro-2H-thiopyranium iodide (8b) (six-membered ring) gave largely the methylated products accompanied by minor ring-opening products (Scheme [3a]).[14] The α-substituents on tetrahydrothiophenium also had an impact on the regioselectivity of alkylation. Treatment of 1,2-dimethyltetrahydrothiophenium iodide (8c) with azide or methanethiolate and reaction of 1,2,6-trimethyltetrahydrothiophenium iodide (8d) with methanethiolate provided mainly or nearly entirely methylated product by displacement at the exocyclic methyl moiety.[14] The SN2 reaction mechanism together with the strain of the five-membered ring might explain the different selectivity of these systems.[14] Taylor and co-workers investigated the reactions of thietane (9) with benzyl halides, yielding 3-halopropyl benzyl sulfides 11 via ring opening of 1-benzylthietanium halide­ intermediates 10 (Scheme [3b]).[15] Different from the reactions of 9 with iodomethane and other halides giving no products or complex mixtures of polysulfides, a variety of 3-bromopropyl benzyl sulfides 11 were successfully synthesized in good to excellent yields by heating 9 and benzyl halides in the presence or absence of solvent.[15] Závada and co-workers reported that reactions of 4-alkyl-4,5-dihydro-3H-dinaphtho[2,1-c:1′,2′-e]thiepin-4-ium 13 with a range of N-, S-, Se-, O-, and C-nucleophiles afforded the corresponding ring-opened bidentate products 14 and/or dealkylative product 12, which was dependent upon the counteranions of the sulfoniums (Scheme [3c]).[16] In most instances, iodide caused the formation of 12, while perchlorate, tetraphenylborate, and tetrafluoroborate favored the production of 14. Alkylation of racemic 12 with iodomethane was a reversible process and required very large excess of iodomethane (about 50-fold) to complete the reaction. This difficulty was overcome by using a non-nucleophilic counteranion (e.g., BPh4, ClO4, or BF4) as the reactions with equimolar methyl perchlorate and Et3O+BF4 afforded alkylsulfonium salts in nearly quantitative yields.[16]

A synthetic route to α-aminoboronic acids 19 as inhibitors of serine proteases using electrophilic alkylsulfonium side chains was developed by Kettner and co-workers (Scheme [4]).[17a] BrCH2CHF2, BrCH2CO2 t-Bu, and CH2=CHCO2Me reacted with the anion of (phenylthio)methaneboronate 15 to give substituted boronates 16, which were converted into the corresponding alkylsulfonium ions 17 by treatment with iodomethane. Simultaneous substitution of the active sulfonium intermediates 17 with iodide formed α-iodo derivatives 18, which underwent amination to afford the expected α-aminoboronic acids 19. This method was particularly advantageous for compounds with functionalities that were sensitive under basic conditions.[17a] Earlier it was reported that there was a chemical equilibrium between alkyl sulfide and alkyl halide, from which the most stable sulfonium salt would be formed.[17b] The use of a large excess of iodomethane was beneficial for the generation of 17 in this reaction.[17a]

Zoom Image
Scheme 4 Synthesis of α-aminoboronic acids by introducing electrophilic alkylsulfonium side chains

Thiiranium intermediates 23 are highly reactive three-membered alkylsulfonium salts that have been widely examined with diverse nucleophiles to furnish a large family of α-functionalized sulfides 24 (Scheme [5]).[1a] [18] These sulfonium intermediates are usually in situ generated from the reactions of electrophilic alkyl- or arylthiolation reagents 20 with alkenes 21 or the intramolecular nucleophilic attack of the sulfur atoms in sulfides 22 at the electron-deficient carbon centers bearing an appropriate leaving group. The regioselectivity of ring opening of thiiraniums 23 is dramatically dependent upon the nature of the nucleophile (Nu) and the substituents (R2 and R3) attached to the three-membered ring.[1a] [18] Since this is an extensive topic, we do not intend to discuss this in detail here, but instead refer the interested reader to reviews on recent achievements in the synthesis and reactivity of thiiranium salts.[18]

Zoom Image
Scheme 5 In situ synthesis and ring opening of thiiranium salts

Iyoda and co-workers reported that the alkylation of tetramethylammonium­ pentacarbonyl(1-oxyalkylidene)metalates 27 with alkyl(diphenyl)sulfonium salts 26 permits a simple synthesis of Fischer-type chromium, molybdenum, and tungsten (alkoxy)carbene complexes 28 with diverse functionalized alkyl groups (Scheme [6a]).[19] The reactions proceeded smoothly to give the corresponding (alkoxy)carbene complexes 28 in good to high yields. Alkyl(diphenyl)sulfonium tetrafluoroborates 26 were readily prepared from the reactions of alkyl halides 25 with Ph2S in the presence of AgBF4. The competitive alkylation of 27a with 26a and 26b showed that the secondary isopropyl(diphenyl)sulfonium salt 26b was more reactive than the primary methyl(diphenyl)sulfonium salt 26a (Scheme [6b]),[19] which implied that the mechanism of this alkylation might involve participation of an S–O sulfurane intermediate 26′ rather than a simple SN2 pathway since the relative reactivities of methyl, ethyl, and isopropyl halides in SN2 reactions are often found to be methyl > ethyl > isopropyl (Scheme [6b]). The formation of 26′ via an electron-transfer process could explain the unusual reactivity of the alkylsulfonium salts towards 27a.[19]

Zoom Image
Scheme 6 Synthesis of Fischer-type (alkoxy)carbene compounds using alkyl(diphenyl)sulfonium salts

# 3.2

Synthesis of β-Lactams, Azetidines, and Furanones through Alkylsulfonium Salts

The stereoselective construction of the β-lactam ring in the synthesis of carbapenem antibiotics is a difficult synthetic task.[20a] In 1993, Naito and co-workers provided a practical method for the chiral synthesis of cis- and trans-β-lactams using the combination of the stereoselective Michael­ addition of thiophenol to α,β-unsaturated carbonyls and subsequent intramolecular substitution of the in situ formed sulfonium group, which was successfully applied to the formal preparation of carbapenem antibiotic 31 (Scheme [7a]).[20a] Initially, stereospecific reaction of thiols with α,β-unsaturated carboxylic acid derivatives 29-I, followed by aminolysis with alkoxyamine hydrochloride and S-alkylation with iodomethane in the presence of silver perchlorate, afforded alkylsulfonium salts 29-III, which then underwent smooth lactamization through intramolecular displacement of the sulfonium group with O-alkylhydroxamate in the presence of potassium carbonate to give β-lactam 30 with high stereoselectivity. In 2015, Jamison and co-workers reported that enantiopure 2-alkylazetidines 33 could be straightforwardly synthesized via consecutive processes including regioselective Ni-catalyzed cross-coupling of organozinc reagents with an aziridine 32-I bearing a phenylthio group, methylation of the phenylthio group to form a sulfonium moiety, and nucleophilic intramolecular substitution under basic conditions (Scheme [7b]).[20b] This sequence tolerated a range of organozinc reagents, giving the products in good overall yields and with excellent selectivity.

Zoom Image
Scheme 7 Synthesis of enantiomerically pure β-lactams and azetidines via alkylsulfonium intermediates

In 2016, Kawano and co-workers disclosed the synthesis of 5-alkoxyfuran-3(2H)-ones 35 from the intramolecular cyclization of 3-(alkoxycarbonyl)-2-oxopropyl(diphenyl)sulfonium salts 37 in the presence of t-BuOK (Scheme [8a]).[21a] Similarly, intramolecular cyclization of (4-aryl-2,4-dioxobutyl)methylphenylsulfonium salts 39 derived from 1-arylethanone 38 produced a family of 5-arylfuran-3(2H)-ones 40 in excellent yields under ambient conditions (Scheme [8a]).[21b] When ethyl 4-chloroacetoacetate (34a) and ethyl 4-bromoacetoacetate (34b) were subjected to the optimal conditions, 35a was observed as a minor product and the dimerization product 36 was the major product (Scheme [8a]).[21a] These results indicated that a bulky diphenylsulfonio group was very important for the cyclization as substrates bearing smaller leaving groups (e.g., Cl, Br) underwent intermolecular SN2 reactions. This strategy also enabled a one-pot preparation of 5-alkoxy-4-alkylfuran-3(2H)-ones 41 from sulfoniums 37 via alkylation with alkyl halides followed by intramolecular cyclization, showing a wide substrate scope and good functional group tolerance (Schemes 8b and 8c).[21a] In addition, halogenative intramolecular cyclization of 37 with NXS (X = Br, I) conveniently furnished a variety of 4-bromo- or 4-iodo-substituted 5-alkoxyfuran-3(2H)-ones 42 as useful synthetic building blocks in good to high yields.[21c] Acylative intramolecular cyclization of alkylsulfonium salts 44 by in situ formation of a mixed anhydride between carboxylic acid 43 and trifluoroacetic anhydride (TFAA) in the presence of N-methylimidazole, followed by sequential acylation and cyclization, was extensively explored, which provided various 2-substituted 4-oxo-4,5-dihydrofuran-3-carboxylates 45 in good yields (Scheme [8c]).[21d]

Zoom Image
Scheme 8 Sulfonium-mediated intramolecular cyclization of 1,3-dicarbonyls

# 3.3

Ring-Opening Alkylation with Cyclic Alkyl(aryl)sulfonium Salts

The ring-opening reactions of cyclic alkyl(aryl)sulfonium salts constitute effective methods for introducing alkylthio groups into organic molecules (Scheme [9]). This strategy was favorably applied in the three-component cascade reactions of aryne precursors, cyclic sulfides, and nucleophiles (HNu).[22] [23] [24] In 2016, Hoye and co-workers revealed the reaction of alkyl sulfide 47 with aryne 46, thermally generated by the hexadehydro-Diels–Alder (HDDA) cycloisomerization of tetrayne 51, produced an aryl anion bearing o-sulfonium moiety that underwent intramolecular proton transfer to form an S-aryl sulfur ylide 48 (Schemes 9a and 9b).[22] This species was trapped via sigmatropic shift or rearrangement to form sulfides 49 or protonated by weak acids (HNu) to produce alkylsulfonium intermediates. In the reactions of cyclic alkyl sulfides, Nu [derived from weak acids (HNu)] was incorporated into the product 50 by ring opening.[22] In 2018, Xu and Tan reported a three-component cascade reaction of o-(trimethylsilyl)aryl triflates 53, cyclic sulfides 54, and C-, N-, O-, or S-nucleophiles 55 through the aryne-activated ring-opening process under mild conditions, giving structurally diverse sulfides in good yields (Scheme [9c]).[23a] Independently, He and co-workers disclosed a similar three-component reaction of aryne precursors 56, four- to six-membered sulfides 57, and divergent nucleophiles 58, including inorganic salts (e.g., KF, KCl, KBr and KSCN), silylated reagents (e.g., TMSCN, TMSN3, TMSCl), and water (Scheme [9d]).[23b] Likewise, Lewis and co-workers described the synthesis of azulenyl sulfides by ring-opening reactions of azulenylsulfonium salts with the thiophenol anion and amines.[24] These strategies allowed convenient syntheses of a large number of useful alkyl aryl sulfides for future applications.[22] [23] [24]

Zoom Image
Scheme 9 Diverse ring-opening alkylation with alkylsulfonium salts generated in situ from benzyne and cyclic sulfides

# 3.4

Alkylsulfonium-Mediated C–F Functionalization

In 2021, Young and co-workers reported that frustrated Lewis pair (FLP) catalyzed monoselective C–F activation of polyfluorocarbons 59 at geminal or distal sites with tris(perfluorophenyl)borane [B(C6F5)3] and tetrahydrothiophene (THT) formed 1-(fluoro)alkyltetrahydrothiophenium intermediates 60 in excellent yields (Scheme [10]).[25] Different from the previous ring opening processes, these cyclic sulfonium salts 60 reacted with nucleophiles through substitution of THT to afford a range of divergent products 61.[25] THT was found to be a superior base working as FLP partner in this C–F activation in terms of reactivity, product yield, and selectivity.

Zoom Image
Scheme 10 FLP-catalyzed monoselective C–F functionalization via 1-(fluoro)alkyltetrahydrothiophenium intermediates

# 3.5

Synthesis and Alkylation of Dicationic Alkylthianthrenium Salts

Alkenes are also important synthons to prepare alkylsulfonium salts.[26] [27] In 1979, Shine and co-workers found that thianthrene and phenoxathiin radical cation perchlorates 63, prepared in situ from the chemical oxidation of thianthrene and phenoxathiin, respectively, could facilely react with a number of alkenes 62 to form alkanedisulfonium diperchlorates 64 in excellent yields (Scheme [11a]).[26a] Thianthrene radical cation perchlorate (TT•+ClO4 ) reacted with cyclohexene (62a) to give 1,2-bis(thianthren-5-ium-5-yl)cyclohexane diperchlorate 64a.[26b] The outcomes of the reactions of 1,2-bis(thianthren-5-ium-5-yl)cycloalkane diperchlorates 64a,b with CN, I, and SPh in dimethyl sulfoxide or ethanol indicated that they have a trans-1,2 structure and could undergo SN2 substitution and E2 elimination at room temperature (Scheme [11b]).[26] Although addition of TT•+ClO4 to 62a gave trans-1,2-bis(thianthren-5-ium-5-yl)alkane diperchlorate 64a, reaction of TT•+ClO4 with cyclooctene afforded only cis-monoadduct 65, 1,2-(thianthrene-5,10-diium-5,10-diyl)cyclooctane diperchlorate.[26c] Similar monoadducts were obtained when TT•+BF4 , TT•+SbF6 , and TT•+PF6 added to cyclooctene. Interestingly, addition of TT•+ to cyclopentene (62b) and cycloheptene provided mixtures of mono- and bisadducts 64 and 65. The proportions of monoadducts obtained in the initial stage of the reactions varied with the size of cycloalkenes 62.[26d] Bis- and monoadducts were also obtained in the addition of TT•+ClO4 to acyclic alkenes, and the relative amounts again changed with the structures of alkenes.[26d] The monoadducts 65 afforded 1-(thianthren-5-ium-5-yl)cycloalkenes 66 by loss of a proton. In both bis- and monoadducts of acyclic alkenes, the configuration of the alkene was retained.[26d]

Zoom Image
Scheme 11 Shine’s pioneer works for the synthesis and reactivity of dicationic alkylthianthrenium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 12 Synthesis of aziridines by electro-generated dicationic thianthrenium-mediated coupling of amines and terminal alkenes

A convenient method for electrochemical synthesis of mono- and bis(thianthrenium) salts was demonstrated by Wayner and co-workers.[27a] The selectivity for the mono- or bis(thianthrenium) adduct was proposed to be governed by the oxidation potential of the distonic radical cation intermediate. In 2021, Wickens and co-workers reported that terminal alkenes 73 were electrochemically transformed into metastable dicationic sulfonium intermediates 74 and 75 that underwent aziridination with primary amines 76 under basic conditions to afford a range of N-alkylaziridines 77 (Scheme [12]).[27b] Since the oxidative alkene activation was decoupled from the aziridination step, a wide range of oxidatively sensitive amines were used as coupling partners for aziridination. This methodology streamlined the synthesis of important complex amines, including medicinally relevant molecules (e.g., 77a), and was extended to other conversions, such as direct diamination of alkenes to give 78 without additional base under the aziridination conditions, formation of dihalogenated product 79 by treatment with halides, and construction of vinyl nitrile 80 with addition of potassium cyanide.[27b]

Zoom Image
Scheme 13 Synthesis of β,γ-unsaturated amines from alkenes via allylsulfonium intermediates

# 3.6

Synthesis of β,γ-Unsaturated Amines through Alkylsulfonium Intermediates

In 2003, Mukaiyama and co-workers explored a sulfonium-mediated method for the preparation of β,γ-unsaturated amines 83 from 1,1-disubstituted and 1,1,2-trisubstituted alkenes 81 in good yields (Scheme [13a]).[28a] The reactions started with the formation of α,β-unsaturated diphenylsulfonium triflates 85 from alkenes 81 and diphenyl(triflyloxy)sulfonium triflate (84), followed by C=C bond migration in 85 to give allylsulfonium triflates 86 with the primary or secondary amines 82, and successive nucleophilic substitution of 86 with 82 to afford the desired products 83. In contrast, the reactions of styrenes with 84 under similar conditions afforded 2-arylvinyl(diphenyl)sulfonium triflates, which were treated with primary amines to give 2-arylaziridines in high yields.[28b] Likewise, Du, Xu, and Li disclosed a sulfonium-mediated allylic C–H amination of terminal olefins 87 with amines 88, probably involving conversion of the secondary carbocations to the primary carbocations or the primary triflates, which was driven by intramolecular electrostatic repulsion in dicationic intermediates (Scheme [13b]).[29a] The reaction of 84 with allylbenzene (87a) initially gives a secondary carbocation 92, which is converted into secondary triflate 93 or an allylsulfonium salt 94 followed by SN2 reaction or both SN2 and elimination reactions with amine to afford the minor product 89a (path a). Alternatively, 92 might rearrange through a phenonium ion 95 to form a primary carbocation 96, a primary triflate 97, or an allylsulfonium salt 98, which react with amine to afford the major product 90a (path b). Interestingly, the same reaction with primary amine provided azetidine 91 by double SN2 attacks. The product distributions varied dramatically depending on the amine and alkene substrates.[29a] In addition, transition-metal-free allylic C–H arylation, epoxidation, and aziridination of alkenes with the respective electrophiles were investigated.[29b] The reactions involved addition of 84 to olefins, deprotonation of sulfonium intermediates under basic conditions, and condensation of the in situ generated allyl sulfur ylides with arylboronic acids, aldehydes, and aldimines, to give allylic functionalized products in good yields,[29b] which were mechanistically different from the previous aminations.


# 3.7

Alkylsulfonium-Mediated MBH Reactions and Their Extension

The Morita–Baylis–Hillman (MBH) reaction is a well-known named reaction that permits α-functionalization of alkenes with electron-withdrawing groups.[30a] Employment of an oxophilic Lewis acid and a sulfide (Lewis base) to form a key β-sulfonium intermediate allowed the reaction to be compatible with more active Michael acceptors and to a wider range of terminal electrophiles (Scheme [14]).[10e] , [30`] [c] [d] [e] [f] [g] [h] [i] In 1998, Kataoka and co-workers reported that a combination of dimethyl sulfide with TiCl4 effected a MBH reaction between acrylonitrile, methyl acrylate, or phenyl vinyl sulfone and aldehyde at room temperature.[30j,k] The reactions might involve a β-sulfonium-TiCl4-stabilized enolate 100 which is generated by conjugate addition of dimethyl sulfide to the TiCl4-activated Michael acceptor, despite the fact that exceptions were also found in some cases.[30a] [j] In 2002, Goodman and co-workers disclosed that Et2O·BF3 together with THT moderately sustained the MBH reaction of methyl vinyl ketone (MVK, 104).[30l] When the reaction was quenched with aqueous acid, allylsulfonium salt 106 was isolated, which provided compelling evidence for the intermediacy of sulfonium species. In 1993, Kim and co-workers revealed that β-sulfonium silyl enol ethers 108 were generated by treatment of the corresponding enone or enal with TBSOTf and dimethyl sulfide at low temperatures.[10e] MBH-type reaction of the β-sulfonium silyl enol ether of cyclohexenone 108a with acetal 109 and TMSOTf, followed by treatment with DBU, afforded O-methylated MBH-adduct 110.[10e] [30b] [m] In 2006, Metzner and co-workers modified Kim’s procedure with Hünig’s base, TBSOTf, and THT, allowing in situ enolization of the β-sulfonium-β′-OMe intermediate and giving the MBH adducts by an aqueous quenching.[30b] Remarkably, β-sulfonium silyl enol ethers 108 underwent facile nucleophilic substitution at the β-position with various nucleophiles including Grignard reagents, the sodium salt of dimethyl malonate, tributyltin azide, tributyltin hydride, enamine, piperidine, triphenylphosphine, and pyridine to form the respective enol silyl ethers in good yields (Scheme [14b]).[10e] These reactions had an increased scope of terminal electrophiles over the tertiary amine-/phosphine-catalyzed conditions and were superior for reactive Michael acceptors. Besides, Kim and co-workers harnessed α-alkoxysulfonium salts 112 by reaction of aliphatic diethyl acetal 111 with TMSOTf and dimethyl sulfide at –78 °C.[30n] This salt was treated with a variety of nucleophiles (e.g., Grignard reagents, CH2=CHCH2TMS, silyl enol ethers, CH2=CHCH2SnBu3, and PhSLi) to afford the corresponding adducts 114 in good yields.

Zoom Image
Scheme 14 Morita–Baylis–Hillman reactions involving 2-enylene sulfonium salts and their substitution reactions with diverse nucleophiles

# 3.8

Radical-Polar Crossovers Involving Alkyltetrathiafulvalenium Intermediates

Tetrathiafulvalene (TTF) was developed as a reliable radical-polar crossover (RPC) catalyst by Murphy and co-workers due to its excellent electron-donor ability in the reductive transformation of arenediazonium salts 115 through alkylsulfonium intermediates 118 (Scheme [15]).[11] In these reactions, the TTF radical cation 117 and aryl radical 116 were first generated from TTF and arenediazonium salts 115 via a single electron transfer (SET) process. Cyclization of the aryl radicals bearing adjacent C=C bonds 116, followed by coupling of the newly formed carbon radicals with the TTF radical cation, formed the key alkylsulfonium intermediates 118. These salts 118 participated in SN1 reactions with nucleophiles including water, alcohols, and acetonitrile to afford a series of functionalized bi- and tricyclic ring systems 119 (Scheme [15b]).[11] However, when tetrathiafulvalenium salt 118a reacted with azide, diethyl malonate, and KOH, unexpected products (e.g., 120) via fragmentation of the tetrathiafulvalenium rings or addition of nucleophile to the central C=C bond of the tetrathiafulvalenium moiety were obtained (Scheme [15c]).[11i]

Zoom Image
Scheme 15 TTF-mediated radical-polar crossover reactions
Zoom Image
Scheme 16 Synthesis of α-substituted ketones through the in situ formed α-carbonyl sulfonium salts from alkynes

# 3.9

Synthesis of α-Heterosubstituted Ketones via α-Carbonyl Sulfonium Salts

A one-pot, transition-metal-free procedure for the synthesis of α-heterosubstituted ketones 123 through sulfonium-mediated difunctionalization of aryl-substituted internal alkynes 121 was described by Li, Du, and co-workers in 2019 (Scheme [16a]).[31a] Initially, 121 attacks Tf2O-activated sulfoxide 84 to form a sulfonium vinyl triflate intermediate 124,[31] which undergoes hydrolysis to give an α-sulfonium ketone 125.[31a] Subsequent substitution of 125 with various nitrogen, oxygen, sulfur, and halogen nucleophiles 122 provides different types of α-substituted ketones 123. The preliminary catalytic asymmetric variant of the reaction gave the desired product with moderate yield and er value (Scheme [16b]).[31a] In 2020, Li and co-workers expanded the reaction scope to both internal and terminal arylalkynes under relatively weak basic conditions using potassium acetate as both base and nucleophile to furnish α-acetoxy ketones, avoiding the unwanted elimination process for terminal alkynes.[31b] Sun, Li, and co-workers disclosed a catalytic asymmetric approach for the synthesis of chiral α-amino ketones 129 with excellent efficiency and enantioselectivity from α-carbonyl sulfonium ylides 126 and amines 128 by a protonation-amination sequence involving an α-carbonyl sulfonium intermediate 127.[32a] The reaction was extended to α-amino esters by varying the chiral catalysts 130. Mechanistic studies indicated that the enantioselectivity of the reaction was controlled by dynamic kinetic resolution in the rate-determining amination step rather than the initial protonation step. Furthermore, the cleavage of the non-ylidic S–C bond of alkyl(aryl)sulfonium ylides was explored.[32b] The ylides served as alkyl cation precursors under acidic conditions and allowed alkylation of alcohols, acids, amines, amides, 2-mercaptobenzothiazole, and electron-rich arenes. If the reaction of alcohols or phenols was performed under alkaline conditions, the cleavage of the S–aryl bond occurred to form O-arylated compounds.[32b] This protocol had excellent compatibility of a wide variety of substrates including carbohydrates.

Zoom Image
Scheme 17 Functionalization of indole derivatives via sulfonium-mediated cascade reactions

# 3.10

Indole Functionalization through Alkylsulfonium Intermediates

Indoles bearing functional groups are often found as key structures in biologically active natural products and pharmaceuticals.[33] In 2011, Kawasaki and co-workers reported the sulfonium-mediated functionalization of indole derivatives 131 with methanol at the 2α-position in the presence of sulfoxide and trifluoroacetic anhydride (Scheme [17a]).[33`] [b] [c] The active thionium species 134 were derived in situ from the alkyl or aryl sulfoxide and TFAA. In addition to methanol, other carbon- and heteroatom-nucleophiles 132 were also directly introduced into 131 to form 133 in excellent yields.[33`] [b] [c] Similarly, a one-pot sulfonium-mediated synthesis of homo- and heterodimeric pyrroloindolines 140 was developed by combination of DMSO and Tf2O (Scheme [17b]).[33d] Intramolecular cyclization of tryptamine with DMSO/Tf2O, followed by substitution with indoles or anilines, produced C3a-nitrogen-linked pyrroloindolines, including several bioactive alkaloids.[33d] [e] The use of 2,3-dihydrotryptamine instead of anilines in the same reaction enabled easy access to 3a-(indol-1-yl)pyrroloindoline and a concise synthesis of (±)-psychotriasine.[33e] In 2016, the enantioselective synthesis of C3a-substituted pyrroloindolines from tryptamine utilizing C 2-symmetric chiral sulfoxides was accomplished in a one-pot procedure, the synthetic utility of which was demonstrated by the facile total synthesis of (+)-psychotriasine.[33f] Moreover, the total synthesis of (+)-gliocladin C was implemented on the basis of a 3a-(indol-3-yl)pyrroloindoline structure that was built by sulfonium-promoted cross-coupling of a tryptophan derivative with indole in the presence of dialkyl sulfoxide and Tf2O.[33g] Likewise, the sulfonium-triggered direct C2-functionalization of indoles 141 with different kinds of nucleophiles 142 was explored (Scheme [17c]).[33h] Reaction of 141 with the in situ formed sulfonium salt from DMSO/Tf2O generates iminium species 144, which is attacked by 142 followed by elimination of dimethyl sulfide, to afford the corresponding C2-substituted indole derivatives 143 in good to high yields.

Zoom Image
Scheme 18 Alkylation of alkene and arenes via interrupted Pummerer reaction and [3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement of allyl- or allenylsulfonium intermediates

# 3.11

Alkylation of Alkenes and Arenes via Allyl- or Allenylsulfonium Salts

In 2009, Yorimitsu, Oshima, and co-workers found that reaction of 2-(2,2,2-trifluoroethylidene)-1,3-dithiane monoxide with allylsilanes, Tf2O, and 2,6-di-tert-butylpyridine through allylsulfonium intermediates afforded β-allylated ketene dithioacetals in good yields (Scheme [18a]).[5d] [34a] The specific C–C bond formation with γ-substituted allylsilanes at the α-position suggested the intervention of [3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement of an allylsulfonium intermediate 149. Initially, an activated sulfonium species 147 is formed in the interrupted Pummerer reaction wherein allylsilane 148 attacks the sulfur atom to generate an allyl(alkenyl)sulfonium salt 149. Subsequently, 149 undergoes [3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement followed by deprotonation to yield the final product 151. This valuable interrupted Pummerer reaction/[3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement sequence was extended to the ortho-selective C–H alkylation of aryl sulfoxides (Scheme [18b]).[34`] [c] [d] [e] [f] Procter and co-workers disclosed a general method for the metal-free ortho-allylation of aryl and heteroaryl sulfoxides 152 with allylsilanes 153 and Tf2O or TFAA as an activator.[34b] [c] Pyrrole and pyrazole sulfoxides underwent a heterocycle-accelerated interrupted Pummerer reaction and thio-Claisen rearrangement to form ortho-allylated products, showing complete regiospecificity with regard to both coupling partners.[34c] In a similar manner, sulfoxide-directed metal-free ortho-propargylation of aromatics and heteroaromatics 156 through an interrupted Pummerer/allenyl thio-Claisen rearrangement enabled propargylic carbon nucleophiles to be added ortho to sulfur atoms on the aromatic or heteroaromatic rings 159.[34`] [e] [f] This cross-coupling procedure was operationally simple and completely selective for products of propargylation over allenylation.

Benzothiophenes represent important scaffolds that are widely found in biological molecules and organic materials. By employing the interrupted Pummerer reaction to capture and deliver allyl- or propargylsilanes 160 or 161, Procter and co-workers accomplished a metal- and directing-group-free preparation of C3-alkylated benzothiophenes 163 from benzothiophene S-oxides 162 under mild conditions (Scheme [18b]).[34g] The method had a broad substrate scope and provided various medicinally relevant C3-arylated products, giving greater diversity in important benzothiophenes. Notably, C2-allylated and C2-propargylated benzothiophenes 165 were also synthesized by a cascade sequence involving interrupted Pummerer reaction of 3-substituted benzothiophene S-oxides 164 with 160 or 161, [3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement of the in situ formed allyl- or allenylsulfonium salts, and 1,2-migration of the 3,3-disubstituted benzothiophenium intermediates.[34h] The facile [3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement and 1,2-migration process ensured complete regioselectivity and tolerated a range of reactive functional groups in both coupling partners. Furthermore, Procter and co-workers reported a dual vicinal functionalization of electron-rich heteroarenes (e.g., 166) via an interrupted Pummerer cross-coupling of allyl or propargyl sulfoxides (e.g., 167) with subsequent charge-accelerated [3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement of the corresponding sulfonium intermediates (e.g., 168), providing biologically relevant C3-sulfanylated and C2-allylated or -allenylated heterocycles (e.g., 169) under mild conditions.[34i] Analogously, a metal-free twofold C–H annulation via an interrupted Pummerer reaction/[3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement/cyclization sequence was harnessed for the preparation of benzothiophenes (e.g., 175) from non-prefunctionalized arenes 170 and allyl sulfoxides (e.g., 171).[34j] This procedure was particularly effective for the synthesis of polyaromatic benzothiophenes from non-prefunctionalized polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs).

Zoom Image
Scheme 19 Cu-catalyzed selective construction of tertiary esters with allylsulfonium salts

#
# 4

Transition-Metal-Catalyzed Alkylation Using­ Alkylsulfonium Salts

4.1

Cu-Catalyzed Alkylation with Allylsulfonium Salts

Because of the electron-deficient nature of sulfur(IV) centers, sulfonium salts easily undergo oxidative addition with transition metals, working as pseudohalides in transition-metal-catalyzed cross-coupling reactions.[8] In 1983, Julia and co-workers disclosed that the transition-metal-free alkylation of carboxylate salts with alkylsulfonium salts showed little dependence upon the substituents attached to the sulfur atoms, while the reactions with allylsulfonium salts in the presence of copper(I) salts were greatly accelerated and selectively transfer the unsaturated residues.[35a] [b] Prenyl sulfonium salts 176, which reacted very efficiently at the α-position without copper salts to form primary esters 178, gave exclusively tertiary esters 179 with a catalytic amount of copper bromide (Scheme [19a]).[35a] Similarly, reactions of tetrabutylammonium dihydrogenphosphate with terpenic allylsulfonium salts gave the corresponding primary terpenic allyl phosphates in fair to moderate yields, whereas the Cu-catalyzed reactions led to the production of tertiary allyl phosphates.[35b] It was demonstrated that the copper(I) catalyst dramatically changes the regioselectivity of the reactions of allylsulfonium salts with nucleophiles.[35] This regioselectivity is probably controlled by forming the reactive π-allyl- or σ-allylcopper intermediate which predominantly undergoes nucleophilic attack at the most substituted carbon sites, yielding the tertiary esters.[35a] [b] Later the strategy was favorably employed by Lipton and co-workers in the one-step synthesis of 1,1-dimethylallyl esters of N-protected amino acids 182 using dimethyl(prenyl)sulfonium tetrafluoroborate (176a) in conjunction with catalytic amount of CuBr (Scheme [19b]).[35c] [d] Sulfonium salt 176a was prepared from prenyl alcohol (180) and dimethyl sulfide in the presence of tetrafluoroboric acid. The alkylation was complete within several hours and afforded 182 in excellent yields and with high regioselectivity. These 1,1-dimethylallyl-protected amino acids were useful materials in the synthesis of tripeptide esters and others.[35c] [d]


# 4.2

Pd- or Ni-Catalyzed Alkylation with Diverse Alkylsulfonium­ Salts

In 1997, Srogl, Liebeskind, and Allred reported the first palladium- and nickel-catalyzed benzylation of organoboron, -tin, and -zinc reagents 185 with a variety of 1-benzyltetrahydrothiophenium salts 184, affording the corresponding benzylated products 186 in moderate to good yields (Scheme [20]).[36] Benzyl- and heterobenzylsulfonium salts 184 were readily synthesized from benzyl alcohols or halides 183 and tetrahydrothiophene. It is worth noting that this pioneering work played an indispensable role in stimulating the rapid development of cross-coupling reactions of sulfonium salts in the last decade.[8]

Zoom Image
Scheme 20 Pd- or Ni-catalyzed benzylation of diverse organometal reagents with benzylsulfonium salts

In 2013, Li and co-workers reported a Pd-catalyzed methylation of terminal alkynes 187 with dimethylsulfonium ylide 188 as a methyl source, yielding a number of methyl-functionalized internal alkynes 189 through a C(sp)–C(sp3) bond formation process (Scheme [21a]).[37] In 2018, Novák and co-workers found that alkyldibenzothiophenium salts 191 were suitable alkylation reagents in the palladium-catalyzed direct ortho-C–H alkylation of acetanilide and aromatic urea derivatives 190, which enabled the transfer of methyl and other alkyl groups (e.g., ethyl, propyl, phenethyl and carboxymethylene groups) from sulfoniums to the aniline derivatives under mild conditions (Scheme [21b]).[38] In a similar manner, Shi and co-workers accomplished a Pd-catalyzed C–H methylation of directing group substituted arenes with 5-(methyl-d 3)-5H-dibenzothiophen-5-ium triflate (DMTT).[13a] Using pyridyl as a directing group, the ortho-bis(d 3-methylation) was achieved, leading to the dimethylated product, while using acetylamino as a directing group and reducing the number of equivalents of DMTT, the mono-d 3-methylation product was detected with only trace amount of ortho-bis(d 3-methylation) product.[13a] The drug molecules (e.g., phenacetin) were also modified by this method, furnishing the d 3-methylated products with high deuterium incorporation.

Zoom Image
Scheme 21 Pd- or Cu-catalyzed C–H alkylation of alkynes and arenes with alkylsulfoniums

In 2021, Wang, Zhou, Yu, and co-workers disclosed an interrupted Pummerer/Pd-catalyzed ring opening/fluorination strategy for the C–H fluoroalkylthiolation of alkenes 193 with cyclic alkyl sulfoxide 194 and Tf2O (Scheme [22a]).[39] The reaction proceeds through an in situ generated cycloalkyl(vinyl)sulfonium intermediate 195, which undergoes Pd-catalyzed ring-opening/fluorination with CsF via selective aliphatic C–S bond cleavage to afford the fluoroalkylthiolated alkene derivatives 196 under an air atmosphere. Since a small amount of the target product was formed in the absence of the catalyst, nucleophilic ring-opening fluorination could not be excluded.[39] This protocol featured broad substrate scopes and good functional group tolerance, showing potential for the synthesis of diverse fluoroalkylthiolated N-heterocycles. The substituent and ring-size effects from sulfonium salts had a big impact on the fluorination (Scheme [22b]).[39] Reaction of sulfonium 197 with CsF under the standard conditions gave a mixture of two fluoroalkylthiolated products 198a/198b, which revealed that the sterically hindered C(sp3)–S bond is much easier to cleave. Treatment of dimethylsulfonium salt 199 with CsF gave methylthiolated alkene 200 in 91% yield with methyl fluoride as the major byproduct. In the case of decyl(methyl)sulfonium salt 201, the cleavage of two different C(sp3)–S bonds occurs to form 202a (16%) and 202b (34%), respectively, as well as 193a (31%). Methyl fluoride, decyl methyl sulfide (RSMe), and decyl triflate were also detected or presumed according to the GC-MS analysis. Interestingly, the standard reaction of methyl(phenyl)sulfonium salt 203 with CsF predominantly provided 204 (41%) and 193a (52%) with PhSMe and PhOTf but not phenyl fluoride. These results suggested that the Me–S bond is easier to cleave than the long-chain alkyl–S bonds, and the Ph–S bond is much easier to cleave than the Me–S bond without occurrence of fluoroarylation under the Pd-catalyzed conditions.[39]

Zoom Image
Scheme 22 Pd-catalyzed ring-opening/fluorination of cycloalkyl(vinyl)sulfonium salts with CsF via aliphatic C–S bond cleavage

In addition, Yorimitsu and co-workers reported a nickel-catalyzed Negishi-type reaction of trialkylsulfonium salts 206 with arylzinc reagents 207 in the presence of cyclohexanethiol (CySH) (Scheme [23]).[40a] The transformation was applicable to the one-pot alkylation of 207 with dialkyl sulfides 205 by combining S-methylation with MeOTf. The alkylation using alkyl(dimethyl)sulfonium salts proceeds selectively via cleavage of the [Calkyl–SMe2]+ bonds. The outcomes of the reaction with trialkylsulfonium triflate 206a bearing three different alkyl groups indicates that the formation of the most stable carbon-centered radicals through C–S bond cleavage by SET from low-valent nickel species 209 to sulfoniums was preferred in the reactions (Schemes 23b and 23c). The intermediacy of radical species was also confirmed by the radical clock experiment.[40a] Further studies showed that CySH might assist the C–S bond cleavage and the recombination of radical species (Scheme [23c]).[40a] Tentatively, reduction of Ni(II) precatalyst followed by comproportionation in the presence of the CyS anion generates a Ni(I)–SCy species 209, the single election transfer of which to trialkylsulfonium triflate forms an alkyl radical and a Ni(II) intermediate 210. Then, recombination of the radical and Ni(II) 210 affords an alkyl-Ni(III) cation 211, which might be trapped by another CyS anion to generate 212. Finally, transmetalation of 212 with 207 yields alkyl(aryl)Ni(III) complex 213 that undergoes reductive elimination to afford 208 and regenerate 209. The alkyl(aryl)Ni(III) species 213 was also possibly derived from transmetalation of 211 with 207 without proceeding through 212.[40a] It was noted that Procter and co-workers had previously reported an interrupted Pummerer process using tetrahydrothiophene S-oxide and styrenes to form alkenyl(alkyl)sulfonium salts, which underwent Ni-catalyzed Negishi cross-coupling with a range of organozinc partners to afford di-, tri-, and tetrasubstituted alkenes in moderate to good yields.[40b] This interrupted Pummerer activation and sulfonium salt formation could be extended to arene and alkyne systems as well.

Zoom Image
Scheme 23 Ni-catalyzed Negishi-type arylation of trialkylsulfonium salts

#
# 5

Photoredox-Catalyzed Alkylation Using Alkylsulfonium Salts

In 2013, Fensterbank, Goddard, Ollivier, and co-workers reported the pioneering application of a triarylsulfonium salt as an alternative aryl radical source in organic synthesis under photocatalytic conditions.[41a] Aryl radicals derived from photoinitiated homolytic reduction of triarylsulfoniums by single electron transfer could participate in C–C bond formation with alkenes. Since 2019, the groups of Ritter, Procter, Wang, and others have contributed greatly to this area, accomplishing convenient and efficient arylation methods for the late-stage functionalization of complex molecules with diverse arylsulfonium salts.[41`] [c] [d] [e] [f] [g] [h] [i] Despite these advances, sulfonium salts that undergo SET processes have been mainly limited to the formation of aryl radicals.[8d] Although several chemical, electrochemical, and photoredox methods were developed to initiate the one-electron reduction of alkylsulfonium salts to stabilized alkyl radicals in the last half of the 20th century,[42–44] the generation of alkyl radicals, especially the non-stabilized ones, from alkylsulfonium salts is still a big challenge. Recently, the emergence of visible-light photoredox catalysis has offered possibilities for the SET-induced transformations of alkylsulfonium salts under mild conditions, wherein various non-stabilized alkyl radicals were effectively generated as key intermediates or coupling partners for synthetically useful transformations.[45] [46] [47] [48]

5.1

Transition-Metal-Catalyzed Photoredox Alkylation­

In 2019, Yorimitsu and co-workers reported a visible-light-mediated radical benzylation of alkenes 215 with 1-benzyltetrahydrothiophenium salts 214 using fac-Ir(ppy)3 as a photocatalyst to give allylbenzenes 216 in good yields (Scheme [24a]).[45] The reaction allowed coupling of various benzylsulfoniums and alkenes and tolerated a range of functional groups such as halogen, ester, and cyano groups. The choice of a suitable counteranion for benzylsulfonium salts was an important issue for the alkylation.[45] The transformation possibly involves the following processes (Scheme [24a]): (1) photoexcited catalyst (PC*) reduces benzylsulfonium 214 to generate benzyl radical 217 and dialkyl sulfide, (2) addition of 217 to alkene 215a produces a new carbon radical 218, (3) single electron transfer from 218 to the oxidized photocatalyst (PC+•) forms a cation 219, and (4) deprotonation of 219 affords the product 216a.

Zoom Image
Scheme 24 Photoredox-catalyzed alkylation with benzylsulfonium salts

In 2020, Novák and co-workers developed a Ni/Ir-catalyzed photoredox system for the synthesis of benzylpyrrolidine derivatives 222 from benzylsulfonium salts 220 and N-Boc-proline 221 with extrusion of CO2 (Scheme [24b]).[46] The reaction enabled the one-step synthesis of 2-benzylpyrrolidines from inexpensive starting materials via C(sp3)–C(sp3) bond formation, which are of high interest in the field of medicinal chemistry. The dual photocatalyzed reaction from deprotonated N-Boc-proline to photoexcited Ir(III) species, producing the N-Boc-pyrrolidine radical and an Ir(II) intermediate.[46] Meantime, oxidative addition of benzylsulfonium with Ni(0) derived from NiCl2 forms a benzyl–Ni(II) complex, which intercepts the pyrrolidine radical to provide an alkyl(benzyl)Ni(III) species. Reductive elimination of alkyl(benzyl)Ni(III) affords the desired product and expels a Ni(I) intermediate. Finally, another SET process occurs to reduce Ni(I) to Ni(0) and oxidize Ir(II) to Ir(III), which regenerates both catalysts.[46]

Zoom Image
Scheme 25 Radical alkylation of different substrates with alkylthianthrenium salts

In 2021, Shi, Lu, and co-workers found that SET-induced fragmentation and transformation of alkylthianthrenium salts under photo- and thermoinduced conditions, especially under mild photoredox systems, generated non-stabilized alkyl radicals for C–B and C–C bond formation (Scheme [25]).[47] Alkylthianthrenium salts were demonstrated as suitable electrophiles for borylation, heteroarylation, alkylation, alkenylation, and alkynylation with different substrates bearing a large range of functional groups under photochemical conditions. The formation of an electron-donor-accepter (EDA) complex among alkylthianthrenium salt 223, bis(catecholato)diboron (B2cat2), and N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMA) was a key to the photoinduced alkyl borylation.[47] On the other hand, the thermoinduced construction of alkylboronates 224 from 223 and B2cat2 was promoted by Lewis base (Et3N) (Scheme [25a]). Moreover, the Ir-catalyzed photoredox reaction enabled transfer of alkyl radicals from alkylthianthrenium 223a to alkenes (e.g., 225), arenes (e.g., 227), and other radical accepters (e.g., 229) to build C–C bonds via radical addition and C–H functionalization (Scheme [25b]). Also in 2021, Shi, Lu, and co-workers expanded the photoredox method to the Cu-catalyzed Sonogashira cross-couplings of 223 with alkynes 231 (Scheme [25c]).[48] Diverse alkylthianthrenium salts were successfully employed in the reactions with great functional group tolerance, affording various alkylalkynes 232 in moderate to good yields. The sensitive C–X (X = Cl, Br, I) bonds that were poorly tolerated in conventional approaches were compatible in this reaction. These alkylthianthrenium reagents could be further used in Cu-catalyzed Kumada reactions.[48]


# 5.2

Transition-Metal-Free Photoredox-Catalyzed Alkylation

Ohmiya, Nagao, and co-workers reported a visible-light-mediated sulfide-catalyzed decarboxylative C(sp3)–O bond formation between alcohol, amide, or thiol nucleophiles 234 and tertiary or secondary alkyl carboxylic acid derived redox active esters 233 via an alkylsulfonium intermediate 242 (Scheme [26a]).[49a] [b] In these reactions, the sulfide radical cation 240 and alkyl radical 241 are first generated from an EDA complex 239 of 233 and organosulfide catalyst 236a. Then, radical-radical coupling of 240 and 241 or single-electron oxidation of 241 by 240 followed by complexation forms 242, which undergoes nucleophilic substitution to afford a variety of ethers, sulfides, and N-alkyl-substituted amides 237 (Schemes 26a and 26b). This strategy could be applied to the N-alkylation of azoles 235.[49c] The protocol was also amenable to the vicinal difunctionalization of alkenes 243, enabling the assembly of various nitrogen, oxygen, and halogen nucleophiles 244 with 243 and 233 into highly functionalized C(sp3)-rich motifs 245 (Scheme [26c]).[49d] The catalytic cycle of the reaction begins similarly with the photoinduced SET within an EDA complex composed of sulfide 236b and 233, which is then coupled with vinylarene 243 to form a benzylsulfonium intermediate. Finally, the benzylsulfonium salt is intercepted by 244 to afford the bifunctionalized products 245. Notably, these reactions did not require transition metals, external oxidants/reductants, and strong acids, featuring advantages such as mildness, high functional group tolerance, applicability to various heteroatom nucleophiles, and ability to the synthesis of drug-like molecules.[49]

Zoom Image
Scheme 26 Photoredox-catalyzed alkylsulfonium-mediated coupling reactions

#
# 6

Conclusion

Recent years have witnessed a reemergence of alkylsulfonium salts serving as valuable alkyl-transfer reagents. These salts have intrigued chemists in the fields of synthesis, materials, and life sciences because of their diversiform structures and rich chemistry. Sulfonium compounds that have been successfully used in alkylation reactions include alkyl(diaryl)-, dialkyl(aryl)-, and trialkylsulfonium salts. They are usually employed in purely isolated forms or in situ generated unseparated forms, undergoing nucleophilic substitution, transition-metal-catalyzed reactions, and photoredox transformation via single-electron reduction to convert a large number of N-, O-, S-, C-nucleophiles, alkenes, arenes, alkynes, organometallic reagents, and others into the corresponding alkylated products in an operationally simple and efficient manner. The sulfonium-participated alkylation featured convenience, mildness, non-volatile alkylation reagents, structurally diversified and readily accessible alkylsulfonium salts, good functional group tolerance, and a wide range of substrates, enabling facile construction of various useful organic molecules from commercially available starting materials.

While numerous synthetic methods have been explored based on alkylsulfonium salts, the alkylations using alkylsulfoniums as the coupling partners are still lacking in comparison with arylations using arylsulfonium salts.[5] [8] Thus, continuous efforts are needed to develop novel catalytic systems and structurally diversified alkylsulfonium salts. The ingenious combination of alkylsulfonium salts with transition-metal catalysis, photoredox methods, electrochemical synthesis, mechanochemistry, and green chemistry would provide future driving forces for advances in alkylation reactions. The regioselective C–S bond cleavage of alkylsulfonium salts bearing different alkyl groups, as well as the chemoselective alkylation of nucleophiles containing several reactive sites with certain alkylsulfonium, are highly sought after and remain challenges at present. The enantioselective alkylation with alkylsulfonium salts is another upcoming issue for chemists. The efficient preparation of diversiform alkylsulfonium salts would also be similarly concentrated as this could benefit alkylation and synthesis of complex molecules. Since alkylsulfonium salts are promising cross-coupling partners for many substrates, this review will hopefully inspire more researchers to participate in and contribute to or use sulfonium chemistry for alkylation. The merits of alkylsulfonium salts over alkyl halides in coupling reactions has future potential in terms of efficiency, scope, and mechanisms. It is anticipated that the use of alkylsulfonium salts as common reagents will enrich the chemist’s synthetic toolkit.[50]


#
#

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.


Corresponding Author

Cheng-Pan Zhang
School of Chemistry, Chemical Engineering and Life Science, Wuhan University of Technology
Wuhan, 430070
China   
Email: cpzhang@whut.edu.cn   

Publication History

Received: 30 September 2021

Accepted after revision: 25 October 2021

Accepted Manuscript online:
25 October 2021

Article published online:
12 January 2022

© 2021. Thieme. All rights reserved

Georg Thieme Verlag KG
Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany


Zoom Image
Ze-Yu Tianis a Ph.D. student at Wuhan University of Technology. He joined the research group of Prof. Cheng-Pan Zhang in November 2016. His research interests are the synthesis and cross-couplings of aryl- and alkylsulfonium salts under transition-metal-catalyzed or transition-metal-free conditions. Yu Ma is a third-year master’s student in the research group of Prof. Cheng-Pan Zhang at Wuhan University of Technology. He obtained his bachelor’s degree in Pharmacy from Hebei University in 2019. His research interests mainly focus on transition-metal-catalyzed allylation with alkylsulfonium salts and its application in drug synthesis. Cheng-Pan Zhang obtained his bachelor’s degree in Pharmacy from Chongqing Medical University in 2005. He received his Ph.D. degree from the Shanghai Institute of Organic Chemistry in 2011 under the supervision of Prof. Ji-Chang Xiao. He was a postdoctoral fellow in Prof. David A. Vicic’s group at the University of Hawai’i from 2011 to 2012. Then, he worked with Prof. John A. Gladysz in Texas A&M University. In 2014, he joined Wuhan University of Technology as a full professor. His current research interests are the reactions of sulfonium salts and the development of transition-metal-catalyzed fluoroalkylation.
Zoom Image
Figure 1 The broad application of alkylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Figure 2 General synthetic methods for alkylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Figure 3 Different alkylation reactions with alkylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 1 Selective N-alkylation of guanosine with trimethylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 2 Selective d 3-methylation with DMTT
Zoom Image
Scheme 3 Selective alkylation of cyclic alkylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 4 Synthesis of α-aminoboronic acids by introducing electrophilic alkylsulfonium side chains
Zoom Image
Scheme 5 In situ synthesis and ring opening of thiiranium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 6 Synthesis of Fischer-type (alkoxy)carbene compounds using alkyl(diphenyl)sulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 7 Synthesis of enantiomerically pure β-lactams and azetidines via alkylsulfonium intermediates
Zoom Image
Scheme 8 Sulfonium-mediated intramolecular cyclization of 1,3-dicarbonyls
Zoom Image
Scheme 9 Diverse ring-opening alkylation with alkylsulfonium salts generated in situ from benzyne and cyclic sulfides
Zoom Image
Scheme 10 FLP-catalyzed monoselective C–F functionalization via 1-(fluoro)alkyltetrahydrothiophenium intermediates
Zoom Image
Scheme 11 Shine’s pioneer works for the synthesis and reactivity of dicationic alkylthianthrenium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 12 Synthesis of aziridines by electro-generated dicationic thianthrenium-mediated coupling of amines and terminal alkenes
Zoom Image
Scheme 13 Synthesis of β,γ-unsaturated amines from alkenes via allylsulfonium intermediates
Zoom Image
Scheme 14 Morita–Baylis–Hillman reactions involving 2-enylene sulfonium salts and their substitution reactions with diverse nucleophiles
Zoom Image
Scheme 15 TTF-mediated radical-polar crossover reactions
Zoom Image
Scheme 16 Synthesis of α-substituted ketones through the in situ formed α-carbonyl sulfonium salts from alkynes
Zoom Image
Scheme 17 Functionalization of indole derivatives via sulfonium-mediated cascade reactions
Zoom Image
Scheme 18 Alkylation of alkene and arenes via interrupted Pummerer reaction and [3,3]-sigmatropic rearrangement of allyl- or allenylsulfonium intermediates
Zoom Image
Scheme 19 Cu-catalyzed selective construction of tertiary esters with allylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 20 Pd- or Ni-catalyzed benzylation of diverse organometal reagents with benzylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 21 Pd- or Cu-catalyzed C–H alkylation of alkynes and arenes with alkylsulfoniums
Zoom Image
Scheme 22 Pd-catalyzed ring-opening/fluorination of cycloalkyl(vinyl)sulfonium salts with CsF via aliphatic C–S bond cleavage
Zoom Image
Scheme 23 Ni-catalyzed Negishi-type arylation of trialkylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 24 Photoredox-catalyzed alkylation with benzylsulfonium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 25 Radical alkylation of different substrates with alkylthianthrenium salts
Zoom Image
Scheme 26 Photoredox-catalyzed alkylsulfonium-mediated coupling reactions