Synlett 2021; 32(06): 587-592
DOI: 10.1055/a-1323-2389
letter

Enantioselective Nucleophilic Aromatic Substitution Reaction of Azlactones to Synthesize Quaternary α-Amino Acid Derivatives

Yi Li
,
Hao Pan
,
Wang-Yuren Li
,
Xiaoming Feng
,

We thank the National Natural Science Foundation of China (21625205 and U19A2014) for financial support.
 


Abstract

An asymmetric organocatalytic nucleophilic aromatic substitution reaction of azlactones with electron-deficient aryls was established. A variety of α-aryl α-alkyl α-amino acid esters and peptides were obtained in decent yields and stereoselectivities. A new bifunctional catalytic mode involving charge-transfer interaction and hydrogen bonding is proposed to explain the enantioselectivity.


#

Quaternary amino acid derivatives are important in biochemistry, drug discovery, and synthetic chemistry.[1] A wide variety of stereoselective methods, including diastereoselective derivations, self-regenerations, and enantioselective syntheses, have been developed to construct quaternary stereocenters from natural amino acid derivatives.[2] Enantio­selective α-substitutions of racemic aldimine Schiff bases or azlactones are the most usual and effective of these methods. Nevertheless, reporting of the direct introduction of an aryl substituent at the α-carbon has been sporadic compared with that of various alkylation reactions.[3] Intramolecular α-arylation through N-to-Cα migration from optically active N-aryl amino acid derivatives provides an alternative route in which a chiral memory effect plays an important role.[4] The typical intermolecular asymmetric catalytic nucleophilic aromatic substitution (SNAr) reaction is challenging due to the dearomatization process involved in the addition–elimination mechanism.[5] The Maruoka group reported that chiral phase-transfer catalysts promoted an asymmetric SNAr reaction of aldimine Schiff bases with electron-deficient aryl fluorides or arene chromium complexes (Scheme [1a]).[6] The Wang group used a formal α-arylation of an azlactone for this purpose (Scheme [1b]).[7] As another useful type of amino acid template, azlactones undergo enantioselective SNAr reactions to provide ready access to both α-aryl α-alkyl α-amino acid derivatives and their related peptide derivatives.[8] We are interested in enantioselective SNAr reactions of azlactones with nitro-group-bearing fluoroarenes, with the aim of expanding the range of suitable substrates.

Zoom Image
Scheme 1 Asymmetric catalytic formal arylations toward quaternary α-amino acid derivatives

Chiral phase-transfer catalysts, especially those based on cinchona alkaloids, are popular in asymmetric SNAr reaction,[6] [9] delivering enantiocontrol through electrostatic interactions in ion pairs between the quaternary ammonium or phosphonium ion and the nucleophile. Our research group has achieved good results in chiral guanidine amide-mediated asymmetric catalytic transformations of azlactones through bifunctional hydrogen-bond activation.[10] However, the requirement for excess base to neutralize the HF generated in the SNAr reaction of fluoroarenes can hamper the effective interaction between the chiral guanidine catalyst and the azlactone, leading to poor enantiocontrol. In addition, the ready formation of molecular electron donor–acceptor (EDA) complexes between the electron-­deficient arene and the nucleophilic partners through noncovalent bonding can weaken interactions between the ­catalyst unit and the reactants.

Here, we report the use of a type of polyaryl-substituted chiral guanidine amide organocatalyst in the presence of K3PO4·H2O as a base for the title reaction. This catalytic system permits efficient enantioselective SNAr reactions of azlactones with aryl fluorides, leading to rapid construction of α-aryl α-alkyl α-amino acid derivatives and peptides. A new catalytic mode in which the electron-rich guanidine unit of the catalyst interacts with the electron-deficient electrophile, in combination with a hydrogen-bonding interaction, delivers stereoselectivity.

We initially chose azlactone 1a and 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (2a) as model substrates to optimize the reaction conditions (Table [1]). To reduce the base-initiated racemic background reaction, the weak base K3PO4 was added to neutralize HF. Due to the predisposition of the arylated azlactone product to undergo ring opening,[8] methanol was added to yield the quaternary amino acid ester as the isolated product. Firstly, several chiral guanidine amide catalysts were examined in CHCl3 at –20 °C. We found that each subunit of the catalyst, including the amide substituent, the amidine substituents, and the amino acid backbone, had a marked influence on the enantioselectivity (Table [1], entries 1–7). Among the N,N′-diphenyl-substituted guanidines G-1 to G-4 with various amide units, the enantiomerically enriched product 3a was obtained only in the presence of the bulkier (triphenylmethyl)amine-based guanidine amide catalyst G-3 (entry 3). Almost no enantiocontrol was found with the aniline, (diphenylmethyl)amine-, or tert-butylamine-based analogues G-1, G-2, and G-4 respectively (entries 1, 2, and 4). Also, an N-aryl substituent on the guanidine subunit was critical, as the dialkyl-substituted catalysts G-5 and G-6 gave poor enantioselectivity, whereas guanidine G-7 containing a phenyl and a cyclohexyl substituent on the amidine unit afforded the product with acceptable enantioselectivity (entries 5–7). Switching the catalyst to the l-piperidine-2-carboxylic acid derived catalyst G-8 led to the formation of a racemic product. To improve the enantioselectivity and yield, we carefully examined the reaction temperature, inorganic base additive, solvent, and concentration of substrates [see the Supporting Information (SI) for details]. To our delight, after a slight modification of reaction conditions by decreasing the reaction temperature and increasing the amount of azlactone and the concentration, we obtained the desired product 3a in 94% yield and 82% ee (entry 9). Next, we examined the effects of various substituents on the C5-phenyl group of the azlactone (see the SI for details), and in the presence of azlactone 1b as the nucleophile, the desired product 3b was obtained in 82% yield and 87% ee (entry 10). When the reaction temperature was further decreased to –60 °C, product 3b was obtained in 82% yield and 89% ee in the presence of 15 mol% of G-3 (entry 11). The use of K3PO4·H2O resulted in a slight improvement in the yield (entry 12). To further test the utility of this organocatalytic asymmetric SNAr reaction, the enantiomer of guanidine G-3 was tested under the standard conditions, and the amino acid derivative ent-3b was obtained in 87% yield and 89% ee (entry 13).

Table 1 Optimization of the Reaction Conditionsa

Entry

Catalyst

Temp (°C)

Yieldb (%)

eec (%)

 1

G-1

–20

74 (3a)

 0

 2

G-2

–20

66 (3a)

 0

 3

G-3

–20

82 (3a)

70

 4

G-4

–20

43 (3a)

 3

 5d

G-5

–20

86 (3a)

20

 6d

G-6

–20

82 (3a)

13

 7

G-7

–20

85 (3a)

66

 8

G-8

–20

55 (3a)

 0

 9e

G-3

–50

94 (3a)

82

10e,f

G-3

–50

82 (3b)

87

11e–g

G-3

–60

82 (3b)

89

12e–h

G-3

–60

85 (3b)

89

13e–h

ent-G-3

–60

87 (ent-3b)

89

a Unless otherwise noted, the first step of the reaction was carried out with 1a (0.1 mmol), 2a (1.0 equiv), K3PO4 (5.0 equiv.), G (10 mol%) in CHCl3 (0.1 M) at –20 °C.

b Isolated yields after derivation.

c Determined by Waters UltraPerformance Convergence Chromatography (UPC2).

d 48 h.

e 2a (2.0 equiv) and 1a (0.1 mmol) in CHCl3 (0.33 M).

f 1b instead of 1a.

g G-3 (15 mol%) was used at –60 °C.

h K3PO4·H2O instead of K3PO4.

With the optimized conditions in hand, we investigated the substrate scope for the synthesis of various amino acid derivatives (Table [2]). We initially focused on the azlactone, which provides various amino acid scaffolds for the α-aryl α-alkyl α-amino acid derivatives. Azlactones 1be bearing electron-donating or electron-withdrawing aryl groups R1 were smoothly converted into the corresponding products 3be in yields of 69–94% and 80–89% ee (Table [2], entries 2–5). The absolute configuration of product 3d was determined to be R by X-ray crystal-diffraction analysis.[11] Next, azlactones derived from phenylalanine analogues were employed. The electronic properties and position of the substituents on the aromatic ring of the benzyl substituent of azlactones 1fk had little influence on the enantioselectivity and reactivity, and the corresponding amino acid esters 3fk were obtained in excellent yields (85–99%) and enantioselectivities (87–93% ee) (entries 6–11). The reaction could also be extended to the alkyl-substituted azlactones 1lo; when a longer reaction time was employed, the corresponding products 3lo were obtained in medium yields and ee values (entries 12–15). Additionally, 1,5-difluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (2b) as the aryl fluoride was subjected to the SNAr reaction to give, after the treatment with methanol, the methoxy-substituted product 3p in 89% yield and 93% ee (entry 16).

Zoom Image
Scheme 2 Direct synthesis of nonnatural peptides. Unless otherwise noted, the conditions for initial the SNAr reactions were the same as those in Table [2]. The resulting mixture was then treated with DAMP (1.0 equiv), Et3N (2.0 equiv), and the appropriate amino acid ester hydrochloride (NuH, 2.0 equiv) at room temperature. The stereoselectivity was determined by UPC2. a K2CO3 was used instead of Et3N. b ent-G-3 (15 mol%) was used.

Table 2 Substrate Scopea

Entry

R1

R2

Yieldb (%)

eec (%)

 1

Ph

Bn

86 (3a)

84

 2

4-FC6H4

Bn

85 (3b)

89

 3

4-ClC6H4

Bn

70 (3c)

85

 4

4-BrC6H4

Bn

69 (3d)

84 (R)

 5

4-MeOC6H4

Bn

94 (3e)

80

 6

4-FC6H4

4-fluorobenzyl

92 (3f)

87

 7

4-FC6H4

4-chlorobenzyl

85 (3g)

87

 8

4-FC6H4

4-bromobenzyl

97 (3h)

89

 9

4-FC6H4

4-methylbenzyl

99 (3i)

91

10

4-FC6H4

3-fluorobenzyl

89 (3j)

93

11

4-FC6H4

3-methylbenzyl

99 (3k)

89

12d

4-FC6H4

Me

67 (3l)

45

13d

4-FC6H4

Et

71 (3m)

64

14d

Ph

Pr

70 (3n)

49

15d

4-FC6H4

CH2Cy

83 (3o)

56

16e

4-FC6H4

3-fluorobenzyl

89 (3p)

93

a Reaction conditions: 1 (0.1 mmol), 2a (0.2 mmol), K3PO4·H2O (5 equiv), G-3 (15 mol%), CHCl3 (0.33 M), –60 °C, 3 d.

b Isolated yield.

c Determined by UPC2.

d 4 d.

e 2b was used.

Next, to explore the utility of SNAr reaction of azlactone further, we investigated a series of amino acid esters as nucleophiles to achieve a direct synthesis of peptides. Transformations of azlactone 1j are summarized in Scheme [2]. Representative nonnatural chiral peptides containing a quaternary stereocenter were obtained smoothly, which is beneficial to biochemistry and medicinal chemistry. With methyl glycinate, the reaction proceeded smoothly in the presence of DMAP (1 equiv) to give the desired dipeptide 3q in 92% yield and 93% ee. The transformations of phenylmethanol and methyl glycylglycinate similarly gave the corresponding derivatives 3u and 3v with good enantioselectivities. When optically pure methyl l-leucinate, methyl l-phenylalaninate, and methyl (S)-2-aminopentanoate were added as nucleophiles, the diastereomers of the corresponding dipeptides 3rt were obtained through the use of the enantiomer of the chiral catalyst. (R,S)-Dipeptides and the related (S,S)-dipeptides with quaternary carbon centers of opposite configuration were directly obtained from the azlactone by using G-3 and ent-G-3, respectively, as catalysts. The scalability of this method was demonstrated by the scaled-up reaction of 1j (2.7 mmol) with 2a (2.0 equiv), which gave the desired chiral amino acid ester 3j in 85% yield (1.12 g) and 87% ee.

In our previous study of chiral guanidine amide organocatalysis,[10] [12] we proposed a general bifunctional catalytic mode for the activation and enantiocontrol in the transformation of azlactones in which the guanidine unit acts as a base to promote the enolization of azlactone 1, and at the same time the electrophile is activated by hydrogen bonding to the amide unit. However, in the current reaction, the aryl substituents on both the amidine unit and the amide are critical in achieving enantioselectivity. In view of the electron-deficient nature of 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (2a) and the color changes that occurred during the reaction, we surmised that another important interaction might be present during the reaction. The UV/vis absorption spectrum of a mixture of 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (2a) with guanidine G-3 showed a clear red shift and the appearance of a yellowish color (Scheme [3a]), which is consistent with the action of 2a as an electron acceptor. In contrast, no signal or color changes occurred with the guanidine and the azlactone, or with 2a and the azlactone. When NMR titration experiments (see SI; S17) were carried out to probe into this interaction, the 1H NMR signal for 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (2a) showed an obvious high-field shift on addition of guanidine G-3, whereas the protons of the phenyl substituent of the amidine unit of the catalyst showed a low-field shift, indicating the existence of a charge-transfer interaction between electron-deficient 2a and the electron-rich rings of guanidine. Moreover, the catalytic performance of G-3, G-4, and G-7 (Table [1]) indicates that steric hindrance by the amide unit also plays an important role in enantiocontrol. We suggest that hydrogen bonding of azlactone 1 occurs with the amide of the catalyst, blocking one side to attachment of the nucleophile.

Zoom Image
Scheme 3 Interactions between catalytic components and the proposed asymmetric catalytic mode for the SNAr reaction

Based on the absolute configuration of the product 3d,[11] as well as the interactions suggested by the above experiments, we propose a possible bifunctional catalytic mode (Scheme [3b]). When guanidine G-3 and 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (2a) are mixed, an unstable EDA complex is generated in which the electrophile is located near the amidine unit of the guanidine. The inorganic base accelerates the formation of an enol derivative of the azlactone, which can be bonded by the amide unit, and its Si-face is shielded by the nearby phenyl group of the amide of the catalyst. Next, an addition reaction occurs from the Re-face of the enolized azlactone to form a σ-complex intermediate, which then undergoes a rapid elimination process to yield the quaternary azlactone derivative (R)-3da. After treatment with methanol, the corresponding amino acetate (R)-3d is obtained as the final product.

In conclusion, we have established a catalytic asymmetric SNAr reaction of azlactones with 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene catalyzed by a chiral bifunctional guanidine organocatalyst.[13] A series of α-aryl α-alkyl α-amino acid esters and peptides were obtained in good yields and high stereoselectivities. The introduction of phenyl-based amidine and amide into the guanidine amide catalyst permits a new bifunctional catalytic mode in which the guanidine serves as an electron donor that interacts with the electron-deficient reactants. Studies on further applications of the chiral guanidine catalysts in asymmetric transformations are underway.


#

Supporting Information


Corresponding Author

Xiaohua Liu
Key Laboratory of Green Chemistry and Technology, Ministry of Education, College of Chemistry, Sichuan University
Chengdu 610064
P. R. of China   

Publication History

Received: 20 October 2020

Accepted after revision: 25 November 2020

Accepted Manuscript online:
25 November 2020

Article published online:
16 December 2020

© 2020. Thieme. All rights reserved

Georg Thieme Verlag KG
Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany


Zoom Image
Scheme 1 Asymmetric catalytic formal arylations toward quaternary α-amino acid derivatives
Zoom Image
Scheme 2 Direct synthesis of nonnatural peptides. Unless otherwise noted, the conditions for initial the SNAr reactions were the same as those in Table [2]. The resulting mixture was then treated with DAMP (1.0 equiv), Et3N (2.0 equiv), and the appropriate amino acid ester hydrochloride (NuH, 2.0 equiv) at room temperature. The stereoselectivity was determined by UPC2. a K2CO3 was used instead of Et3N. b ent-G-3 (15 mol%) was used.
Zoom Image
Scheme 3 Interactions between catalytic components and the proposed asymmetric catalytic mode for the SNAr reaction